The foremost managementoriented evaluation approach was developed by daniel. Evaluation modelsabstract western michigan university. You must use your judgment to decide the best course of action and the leadership style needed for. Conceptualizations that guide evaluation work must keep pace with the growth of theory and practice in the field. Further, the design and conduct of any particular study involves a good deal of localized conceptualization. Kenneth alford, a doctorate candidate at the university of the cumberlands, details two separate program evaluations conducted in his school district and seeks to compare and contrast the two evaluations based upon the characteristics of the managementoriented approach. Evaluation models, approaches, and designs sage publications.
Degree program relating to program evaluation models. Evaluation models and approaches the following models and approaches are frequently mentioned in the evaluation literature. Pdf in the 21st century, evaluation in education has been paid great attention and the evaluation. Evaluation is the systematic process of delineating, obtaining, reporting, and applying descriptive and. In this paper the guidelines of modeling gom, a framework to structure factors for the evaluation of process models, is presented. Special issue designing and using program evaluation as a tool for reform margaret e. Participatory evaluation can help improve program performance by 1 involving key stakeholders in evaluation design and decision making, 2 acknowledging and addressing asymmetrical levels of power and voice among stakeholders, 3 using multiple and varied methods, 4 having an action component so that evaluation findings are useful to the programs end. There are a variety of evaluation designs, and the type of evaluation should match the development level of the program or program activity appropriately. In the goalfree evaluation model developed by michael scriven 1991, the evaluation looks at a programs actual effect on identified needs. This consideration led to the object oriented quality management model oqm model. What you do in one situation will not always work in another. In the technology sector, steve jobs is one of the most celebrated leaders.
Special issue designing and using program evaluation as a. Goalfree model, transaction model, decisionmaking model. The historical development of program evaluation opensiuc. A model of process oriented project management education. Types of evaluation centers for disease control and. This project was supported by grant number 2003ddbx k101 awarded to the institute for law and justice by the national institute of justice, office of justice pr ograms, u.
Best practices for health systems and acos, second edition v about the author karen zander, rn, ms, cmac, faan karen zander, rn, ms, cmac, faan, president and ceo of the center for case manage ment in wellesley, massachusetts, has more than 40 years of healthcare experience. Two management oriented samples details two examples of the management oriented approach to program evaluation. Program evaluation defined in characterizing and assessing evaluation approaches, the various kinds of activities conducted in the name of program evaluation were classified on the basis of their level of conformity to a particular definition of evaluation. Aucd the council on research and evaluation webinar march 5, 2014, from 3. Best practices for health systems and acos, second edition v about the author karen zander, rn, ms, cmac, faan. The paper provides readers with comprehensive discussions on the four wellknown evaluation models in education. Process models, on the other hand, especially the organisational shrm models, have reached a more advanced stage of development. The case of a language teaching institute both at home and from across southeast asia. Performance management performance model a systemsbased. Likewise, the systems approached of logic models and program theory focus on inputs, processes, and outcomes, as do the managementoriented evaluation approaches. Developers of the managementoriented evaluation approach and their contribu slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Alexander and hedberg 1994 summarise the representative approaches used in educational research over the past 50 year and give the following four key paradigms with their perceived advantages and disadvantages. The judgments of each of the nine approaches were reached. Instead, the evaluation examines how and what the program is doing to address needs in the client population.
It provides a comprehensive summary of the systemsbased approach to. In order to provide evaluation approach at the design phase, this paper analyzes the service oriented process from two dimensions that evaluate technology complexity, and system performance. Understanding and selecting evaluation models and approaches understanding and selecting evaluation designs the following information is provided as a brief introduction to the topics covered in these activities. The nature of management, mainly in a qualitative sense that is determined by its main content, managerial processes and relationships, as performed through people and on people. Performance evaluation models for strategic decision. Corresponding to the letters in the acronym, cipp, are the. Group division of simplify compliance, lc case management models. Ucla evaluation model with respect to their sensitivity to the various decisions managers need to make at each stage of program development. While goaloriented approaches to treatment, evalua tion, decisionmaking and management practice have proliferated, few descriptions of these approaches contain specific information to guide the evaluation researcher seeking to establish and measure program goals. Evaluation models for service oriented process in spare. Fundamental to the cipp model is the belief that the most important purpose of evaluation is not to prove but rather to improve.
Decisionsaccountabilityimprovement oriented evaluation models and strategic decisionmaking 145. Exemplary, guidelines of modeling for workflow management and. Performance management model 19 the international journal of public sector management, vol. Results oriented management and accountability the monitoring and assessment task force matf, a task force of federal, state, and local csbg network officials, created roma in 1994. Managementoriented models of business processes request pdf. Application of context input process and product model in.
Introduction many great leaders have led companies to growth and prosperity in various ways with different styles. Implementation of these evaluation models helps organizations analyze the business processes and further improve them through the analysis. As stated by usun 2012, these models may be evaluated as disadvantageous as they are costly, necessitate hard efforts for the time and preparation of. The managementoriented approach is very systematic in its. Management is largely dependent on the human factor, and often. Evaluation models, approaches, and designs sage research.
Performance management performance model a systems. The consumeroriented approach to evaluation is the evaluation orientation advocated by evaluation expert and philosopher michael scriven. Context stufflebeam advanced the procedure for conducting a context evaluation with his guidelines for designing a needs assessment for an educational program or activity. Further, the measurement can be oriented to meet the needs of any school district from large to smalland it can focus on a specific evaluation of a districts curriculum area, such as reading, language arts, math, or any content area designated. In this manner, evaluation is viewed as a functional activity where the primary purpose is to strengthen and improve programs and provide a recursive approach to continuous program improvement. Participantoriented evaluation presentation 2 social. However, after several years, this purpose was expanded to cater to the teaching and learning of southeast asian languages in addition to english. Mixedmethods design for an objectivebased evaluation of a magnet school assistance project. Based, experimental studies, management information systems, criticism and connoisseurship, mixed methods, benefit. Evaluation models for evaluating educational programs helpdesk. Aucd the council on research and evaluation webinar march. The use of the dynamic approach in the management field must consider several.
Ross auburn university the auburn university educational leadership team and its k12 practitioner and community partners collaboratively developed a comprehensive, ongoing evaluation plan to assess a newly implemented fieldbased graduate program. Likewise, the systems approached of logic models and program theory focus on inputs, processes, and outcomes, as do the management oriented evaluation approaches. Tylers objective model, stakes responsive model, scrivens goal free model. Local caas are encouraged to undertake a number of roma implementation actions that focus on results oriented management and accountability. Managementoriented evaluation approach is one of the most important approaches serving managers who are. Participatory evaluation can help improve program performance by 1 involving key stakeholders in evaluation design and decision making, 2 acknowledging and addressing asymmetrical levels of power and voice among stakeholders, 3 using multiple and varied methods, 4 having an action component so that evaluation findings are useful to the programs end users. Performance management systems and performance measurement performance management or resultsbased management is a strategy designed to achieve changes in the way organizations operate, with improving performance better results at the core of the system. Evaluation models stufflebeam 2001 new directions for. Outcomebased evaluation obe model, and the fourstep training. In the competitor oriented evaluation approaches, the key philosophy is to get the opinions of two different evaluation specialist being for and against the curriculum unal, 20.
In other words, program goals are not the criteria on which the evaluation is based. While goal oriented approaches to treatment, evalua tion, decisionmaking and management practice have proliferated, few descriptions of these approaches contain specific information to guide the evaluation researcher seeking to establish and measure program goals. The approach stems from the belief that evaluation ought to serve the consumer, that is, the ultimate end user of the particular object under evaluation, the evaluandbe it a program, a curriculum, a. This evaluation and analysis is actualized through the new csbg annual report that will replace the csbg is beginning in ffy 2018.
The emphasis of this approach is to help consumers choose among competing programs or products. Discuss how the choice of the cipp model of management. Based upon principles contained in the government performance and results act of 1993, roma provides a framework for continuous growth and improvement among. In this monograph, evaluation means a study designed and conducted to assist. Objectivesoriented evaluation approach by josh kinchen on. The managementoriented approach to evaluation was instrumental in showing evaluators and program managers that they need not wait until. They are critical tools for forwardlooking strategic positioning, organisational learning and for sound management. As a function of this strategic role, different evaluation models have. Discuss how the choice of the cipp model of management oriented evaluation approach as the evaluation model of choice introduction cipp stands for context, input, process and product, which generally refer to the core concepts that this evaluation model assesses.
You must use your judgment to decide the best course of action and the leadership style needed for each situation. Aucd the council on research and evaluation webinar march 5. Performance management systems serve strategic, administrative, and developmental purposes. Management oriented evaluation approaches slideshare. Cost analysis, performance testing, and objective testing programs were judged to have restricted though beneficial use in program evaluation. As described in chapter 2, the use of models in environmental regulatory activities varies widely both in the effort and the consequences of the regulatory efforts it. The conceptualization of evaluation can never be a onetime activity nor can any conceptualization be static. Evaluation and program planning, 281, 109118, issn 01497189, retrieved from. Two managementoriented samples details two examples of the managementoriented approach to program evaluation. Project management education has never been more popularnor as appropriately well designedthan today. These approaches can be integrated either in a topdown or bottomup oriented way, as is it shown in fig. But because it is difficult to aptly transfer knowledge of project management tools and techniques from the classroom to the meeting room, educational programs often fail to provide project managers with the pathway they need to successfully manage and deliver projects. Aug 26, 2017 ucla evaluation model with respect to their sensitivity to the various decisions managers need to make at each stage of program development. Evaluation approach focusing on the participants participants have interest in the results developed in response to the needs and interests of those associated with the evaluation participant oriented evaluation.
Example objectivesoriented evaluation approach josh kinchen luo, m. Types and uses of evaluation in order to plan the evaluation in accord with the most appropriate evaluation method, it is necessary to understand the difference between evaluation types. The motivational models for stimulating change are introduced in order to trigger some behavioural change for quality pm. Helen paxton, director of communications rutgers faculty of management 2016485177 fax 6481006 email. Kenneth alford, a doctorate candidate at the university of the cumberlands, details two separate program evaluations conducted in his school district and seeks to compare and contrast the two evaluations based upon the characteristics of the management oriented approach. Steve jobs vadim kutsar, nabarun ghose, yuriy kutsar college of business the university of findlay 1. In the competitororiented evaluation approaches, the key philosophy is to get the opinions of two different evaluation specialist being for and against the curriculum unal, 20. Uses instruments as its methodology through observation, interview, survey, test and experiments. Input reinhard developed a guide for use in input evaluation called the advocate team technique. Discuss how the choice of the cipp model of managementoriented evaluation approach as the evaluation model of choice introduction cipp stands for context, input, process and product, which generally refer to the core concepts that this evaluation model assesses.
171 571 405 1329 1557 1404 87 526 1372 1262 226 1060 388 1244 257 981 830 878 78 922 326 594 659 902 522 810 1391 19 1541 1163 505 19 679 1379 1388 678 1498 995 992 1398 1040 1189 454 657